How to Prevent Coiling Machine Reel Overrun

2025-12-03

Reel overrun is one of the most frustrating problems on a coiling line. One minute the machine is running smoothly; the next, the reel spins freely, wire loops start forming, tension collapses, and the operator is forced to stop the machine, unwind the mess, and restart the cycle.
Most operators describe it as “the reel suddenly taking off on its own,” but overrun is never random. It is a predictable result of mechanical imbalance, poor dancer control, low braking torque, or mismatched synchronization between the pay-off, coiler, and traverse.

When not fixed properly, reel overrun increases scrap rate, damages insulation, and ruins packaging consistency—especially on high-speed automatic coilers used for LAN cable, automotive wire, building wire, and soft PVC/PE products.

This guide breaks down the true engineering causes, how to isolate them, and how to eliminate reel overrun permanently.


1. What “Reel Overrun” Actually Means in Engineering Terms


Reel overrun occurs when the reel rotates faster than the linear cable feed speed.
In simple terms:

Reel rotational speed > incoming cable speed → slack → looping → tangling → emergency stop.

A stable coiling system requires the following to stay synchronized:

  • line speed (extruder or production line output)

  • coiling head torque

  • traverse movement

  • tension system (dancer / accumulator / load cells)

  • reel braking and inertia compensation

If any of these components fall out of balance, overrun appears instantly.


2. Fast Diagnostic: How to Identify the Root Category of Overrun


When a reel overruns, observe what happens first:

Case A: Slack appears immediately during startup

Braking torque too weak or reel inertia un-compensated.

Case B: Slack appears when the machine accelerates

Dancer response too slow, servo gain too low, or control loop delay.

Case C: Slack appears at constant speed

Pay-off synchronization drifting or coiling torque not matching load.

Case D: Slack forms only near full reel capacity

Reel inertia increasing faster than the braking unit can handle.

Case E: Slack occurs randomly

→ Check gearbox backlash, mechanical slip, or sensor noise.

Once you categorize the behavior, the real troubleshooting becomes straightforward.


3. Mechanical Causes and Solutions


Mechanical issues account for more than half of reel overrun failures—especially in older or non-servo coilers.

3.1 Undersized or Worn Reel Brake

If the mechanical brake can’t provide consistent stopping torque, the reel will keep spinning even after tension drops.

How to test:

  • Spin reel by hand and engage brake.

  • If stopping distance is inconsistent, the brake is worn.

  • Measure torque with a torque meter to confirm spec.

Fix:

  • Replace brake pads or friction plates.

  • Upgrade to servo-controlled brake for high-speed lines.

  • Increase brake pre-tension for heavy reels.

3.2 Inertia Miscalculation for Larger Reels

Reel mass dramatically increases as the coil grows.
A machine calibrated for a 2 kg empty reel may fail at 12–15 kg full load.

Symptoms:

  • Overrun appears only after 70–90% reel fill.

  • Traverse moves normally, but reel free-wheels slightly.

Fix:

  • Update coiler torque profile to compensate for reel mass growth.

  • Reconfigure machine for heavier max-coil weight.

  • Add active inertia compensation (servo-based).

3.3 Loose Belts / Chain Transmission Slip

A classic, often ignored problem.

Signs of slip:

  • Slight vibration near the reel shaft

  • Reel speed fluctuates visibly

  • Marks appear on belt or chain links

Fix:

  • Re-tension belts

  • Replace worn sprockets

  • Switch to direct-drive if available

3.4 Bearing Drag or Excessive Friction

Contrary to intuition, too much friction can also cause overrun.
Why? Because operators compensate with too much torque, then lose stability during transitions.

Fix:

  • Replace high-friction bearings

  • Re-lubricate according to load class

  • Use low-friction precision bearings on high-speed coilers


4. Control System Causes and Solutions


Servo synchronization and tension loop tuning determine 90% of coiling stability on modern equipment.

4.1 Dancer Response Too Slow

A common cause: dancer arm moves, but servo reacts late, leaving slack.

Fix:

  • Increase dancer PID responsiveness

  • Raise sampling frequency above 500–1000 Hz

  • Reduce mechanical mass of dancer for faster reaction

  • Switch to load-cell feedback if dancer is too slow for thin cables

4.2 Pay-Off and Coiler Out of Sync

If pay-off pushes cable faster than the coiler consumes it, slack forms immediately.

Fix:

  • Re-calibrate both servos to the same line speed reference

  • Zero all encoders

  • Separate pay-off and coiler drives (avoid shared control loops)

  • Ensure communication uses digital feedback, not analog (no delay)

4.3 PLC Scan Time Too Long

If the PLC updates tension values slower than real-time changes, overrun will appear during transitions.

Fix:

  • Move tension loop to dedicated motion controller

  • Reduce PLC load

  • Increase CPU performance or cycle speed

  • Use high-priority task scheduling


5. Sensor and Feedback-Related Causes


5.1 Faulty or Noisy Tension Sensor

If the tension reading jumps, the servo will misinterpret slack and over-correct.

Fix:

  • Replace sensors exceeding ±5% drift

  • Add signal filtering

  • Re-align sensor mount (very common issue)

5.2 Dancer Position Sensor Scaling Incorrect

If the dancer potentiometer or encoder gives incorrect scaling, the machine will under-compensate.

Fix:

  • Re-scale dancer travel range

  • Re-calibrate signal conversion

  • Replace worn potentiometers


6. Process-Level Causes and How to Fix Them


6.1 Line Speed Too Low for Reel Rotation

If line speed drops but coiler torque stays constant, overrun appears.

Fix:

  • Use proportional torque control linked to real line speed

  • Activate “slowdown synchronization” logic

  • Install automatic torque reduction for low-speed zones

6.2 Sudden Line Speed Changes

Overrun often appears during:

  • start-up

  • acceleration

  • deceleration

  • emergency stops

  • coil-change cycles

Fix:

  • Smooth speed profile (S-curve acceleration)

  • Add pre-brake activation before speed reduction

  • Enable servo predictive torque compensation

6.3 Incorrect Reel Size Parameter

Wrong diameter = wrong calculated rpm = instant overrun.

Fix:

  • Operator training

  • Automatic reel diameter detection (recommended for high-speed coilers)


7. Engineering Best Practices to Eliminate Reel Overrun Permanently


These methods are used by factories producing high-end LAN and automotive cables.

7.1 Use Closed-Loop Servo Control Instead of Mechanical Friction Brakes

Mechanical brakes cannot adapt to changing coil diameter.
Servo torque control eliminates overrun by adjusting in real time.

7.2 Upgrade to Load-Cell Tension Control

Dancers are good, load-cells are better—especially for thin wires (0.3–1.0 mm).

Benefits:

  • faster response

  • less vibration

  • more accurate tension stabilization

  • better performance at high speeds

7.3 Install Anti-Overrun Safety Logic

Recommended PLC logic:

  • automatic braking if dancer leaves mid-range

  • soft-stop instead of emergency stop

  • automatic tension recovery

  • torque limiting on empty reels

  • inertia compensation per reel diameter

This alone can reduce overruns by up to 60–80%.

7.4 Keep Traverse in Perfect Sync with Reel

When traverse and reel are out of sync, tension waves cause sudden slack.

Fix by:

  • recalibrating traverse pitch

  • aligning start position

  • checking servo backlash

  • tightening mechanical guides

7.5 Perform Weekly Mechanical Inspection

Checklist:

  • belt tension

  • brake pads

  • reel shaft alignment

  • bearing friction check

  • vibration analysis

  • torque calibration

Preventive maintenance is the cheapest solution of all.


Conclusion: Reel Overrun Is Not an Operator Problem — It’s a System Coordination Problem


When a coiling machine overruns, the first instinct is to blame the operator or “line speed fluctuations.”
But reel overrun always follows predictable causes:

  • insufficient braking torque

  • inertia imbalance

  • poor tension control

  • servo or PLC delay

  • sensor miscalibration

  • mechanical transmission drift

Once the mechanical, control, and tension loops are brought into alignment, reel overrun disappears—even at high coil weights and high line speeds.


We use cookie to improve your online experience. By continuing to browse this website, you agree to our use of cookie.
Cookies
Please read our Terms and Conditions and this Policy before accessing or using our Services. If you cannot agree with this Policy or the Terms and Conditions, please do not access or use our Services. If you are located in a jurisdiction outside the European Economic Area, by using our Services, you accept the Terms and Conditions and accept our privacy practices described in this Policy.
We may modify this Policy at any time, without prior notice, and changes may apply to any Personal Information we already hold about you, as well as any new Personal Information collected after the Policy is modified. If we make changes, we will notify you by revising the date at the top of this Policy. We will provide you with advanced notice if we make any material changes to how we collect, use or disclose your Personal Information that impact your rights under this Policy. If you are located in a jurisdiction other than the European Economic Area, the United Kingdom or Switzerland (collectively “European Countries”), your continued access or use of our Services after receiving the notice of changes, constitutes your acknowledgement that you accept the updated Policy. In addition, we may provide you with real time disclosures or additional information about the Personal Information handling practices of specific parts of our Services. Such notices may supplement this Policy or provide you with additional choices about how we process your Personal Information.


Cookies

Cookies are small text files stored on your device when you access most Websites on the internet or open certain emails. Among other things, Cookies allow a Website to recognize your device and remember if you've been to the Website before. Examples of information collected by Cookies include your browser type and the address of the Website from which you arrived at our Website as well as IP address and clickstream behavior (that is the pages you view and the links you click).We use the term cookie to refer to Cookies and technologies that perform a similar function to Cookies (e.g., tags, pixels, web beacons, etc.). Cookies can be read by the originating Website on each subsequent visit and by any other Website that recognizes the cookie. The Website uses Cookies in order to make the Website easier to use, to support a better user experience, including the provision of information and functionality to you, as well as to provide us with information about how the Website is used so that we can make sure it is as up to date, relevant, and error free as we can. Cookies on the Website We use Cookies to personalize your experience when you visit the Site, uniquely identify your computer for security purposes, and enable us and our third-party service providers to serve ads on our behalf across the internet.

We classify Cookies in the following categories:
 ●  Strictly Necessary Cookies
 ●  Performance Cookies
 ●  Functional Cookies
 ●  Targeting Cookies


Cookie List
A cookie is a small piece of data (text file) that a website – when visited by a user – asks your browser to store on your device in order to remember information about you, such as your language preference or login information. Those cookies are set by us and called first-party cookies. We also use third-party cookies – which are cookies from a domain different than the domain of the website you are visiting – for our advertising and marketing efforts. More specifically, we use cookies and other tracking technologies for the following purposes:

Strictly Necessary Cookies
These cookies are necessary for the website to function and cannot be switched off in our systems. They are usually only set in response to actions made by you which amount to a request for services, such as setting your privacy preferences, logging in or filling in forms. You can set your browser to block or alert you about these cookies, but some parts of the site will not then work. These cookies do not store any personally identifiable information.

Functional Cookies
These cookies enable the website to provide enhanced functionality and personalisation. They may be set by us or by third party providers whose services we have added to our pages. If you do not allow these cookies then some or all of these services may not function properly.

Performance Cookies
These cookies allow us to count visits and traffic sources so we can measure and improve the performance of our site. They help us to know which pages are the most and least popular and see how visitors move around the site. All information these cookies collect is aggregated and therefore anonymous. If you do not allow these cookies we will not know when you have visited our site, and will not be able to monitor its performance.

Targeting Cookies
These cookies may be set through our site by our advertising partners. They may be used by those companies to build a profile of your interests and show you relevant adverts on other sites. They do not store directly personal information, but are based on uniquely identifying your browser and internet device. If you do not allow these cookies, you will experience less targeted advertising.

How To Turn Off Cookies
You can choose to restrict or block Cookies through your browser settings at any time. Please note that certain Cookies may be set as soon as you visit the Website, but you can remove them using your browser settings. However, please be aware that restricting or blocking Cookies set on the Website may impact the functionality or performance of the Website or prevent you from using certain services provided through the Website. It will also affect our ability to update the Website to cater for user preferences and improve performance. Cookies within Mobile Applications

We only use Strictly Necessary Cookies on our mobile applications. These Cookies are critical to the functionality of our applications, so if you block or delete these Cookies you may not be able to use the application. These Cookies are not shared with any other application on your mobile device. We never use the Cookies from the mobile application to store personal information about you.

If you have questions or concerns regarding any information in this Privacy Policy, please contact us by email at . You can also contact us via our customer service at our Site.